5 Indie Horror Games to Track This Month
From Michael Myers to a haunted farming sim, September 2026 stacks its horror slate with variety worth watching.
September 2026 leans hard into horror, and the indie side is doing more than jump scares. This month's slate runs from slasher asymmetry to psychological dread to a spooky farm sim. Here are five upcoming horror games worth tracking now.
- September 8: 1 release
- September 10: 2 releases
- September 17: 1 release
- September 22: 1 release
- OUT NOWPS5STEAMXBOX
Halloween: The Game
Illfonic, the studio behind asymmetric multiplayer horror, turns to one of the genre's biggest icons. Set on Halloween night, 1978, this puts you in the role of Michael Myers as the Boogeyman or as prey trying to survive the face of evil. It lands Sep 8 on PC, PS5, Steam, and Xbox, and it carries the highest hype of this month's picks. If you want a horror night with friends this Halloween season, this is the one to circle first.
- OUT NOWGOGPS5STEAMSWITCHXBOX
Well Dweller
Kyle Thompson's Well Dweller reframes horror as a dark fairy tale, wrapping dread in a metroidvania with adventure, platforming, and RPG threads. You play Glimmer, a tiny bird armed with a matchstick, tasked with burning a wicked queen to save his family in a wretched kingdom. That premise promises charm and cruelty in equal measure. Out Sep 22 across GOG, PC, PS5, Switch, and Xbox, it is the most exploratory pick here, worth tracking if you like your horror with a storybook edge.
- OUT NOWPS5STEAMXBOX
BrokenLore: Don't Lie
Serafini Productions expands its BrokenLore world with a psychological horror spin-off of DON'T WATCH. This entry, DON'T LIE, builds its dread around lies, medication, and fragile bonds that blur reality and nightmare. That focus on unreliable perception is fertile ground for genuine psychological horror rather than cheap shocks. It arrives Sep 10 on PC, PS5, Steam, and Xbox. If you followed the earlier BrokenLore games, or just want a story-driven scare, keep an eye on this one as the month kicks off.
- OUT NOWSTEAM
Welcome to Elderfield
Chris Cote's Welcome to Elderfield blends cozy and creepy into a spooky farming RPG. You can farm, fish, mine, cook, craft, and befriend townsfolk, but you can also beseech the old gods, investigate mysteries, watch unsettling news programs, get lost in a dead mall, and die in your sleep. That mix of daily routine and quiet dread is the hook. It launches Sep 10 on Steam. Track it if you want horror that seeps in slowly between chores rather than screaming at you.
- OUT NOWSTEAM
Lily's World XD
SonderingEmily's Lily's World XD sets its horror inside a found laptop from 2004. You read Lily's diary, message her friends, and piece together what happened to her before it is too late, all while someone else shares access to that computer. It is a fourth wall-breaking psychological horror experience featuring LilyPichu, mixing point-and-click, puzzle, and visual novel elements. Out Sep 17 on PC, it is the most intimate pick here. Track it if desktop-set mysteries and creeping unease are your kind of scare.
